I'm pretty particular about my makeup, and like I've mentioned before, I'm really loyal once I find something I love! I branched out and tried this Make Up Forever eyeliner pencil a few years ago, when I was pretty disappointed with my previous one, and I haven't looked back since. I'm lacking in the fine-motor skills department, so gels and liquid liners have always kind of overwhelmed me, so I've always stuck to pencils, even though experts say gels can last longer. I'm all about finding what is a workable product for you, and this one is perfect for a pencil. It goes on smoothly, without tugging gentle eyelid skin, is easily "smudge able" for the first couple minutes if you're looking for a smokey eye, but after those first few minutes, it stays in place all day long, without migrating or wearing off! I do use makeup remover to get it off at the end of the day, it's tough to take it off without that, but not difficult with remover. An added note- I have pretty sensitive eyes and wear contact lenses, and this has never bothered them one bit! You can buy it here.